Selena Gomez opened the American Music Awards performing two songs. And though many thought the performance was amazing, many took to Twitter to point out she was singing completely off-key for her new single, “Lose You to Love Me.”

Some fans have come to Gomez’s defense saying the lyrics mention singing off-key and wonder if she took that literally. “You promised the world and I fell for it / I put you first and you adored it / Set fires to my forest / And you let it burn / Sang off-key in my chorus / ’Cause it wasn’t yours.”

Those coming to her defense are wondering if Gomez was purposefully singing off-key. But either way, people have a lot to say. Take a look for yourself:

But, on the other hand, bestie Taylor Swift and Halsey seemed to have liked the performance. And that’s all that really matters, right?